A note on Platter wines rating less than four stars

Platters-2015I had a query from one of the handful of people who’ve seen Platter’s 2015 already – someone rather puzzled by what at first glance looks like a rather haphazard way of dealing with wines scoring less than four stars.

Unlike previously, many of them have no words at all – just a star rating. But some of them do have brief descriptions! Huh? I agree it does look rather odd, but there is some system to it. This is it, as I understand it:

The default position is that all wines scoring less than 4 stars get only a rating. (This was a space-saving mechanism, basically, as the total number of wines kept on rising and the number of pages available didn’t.) But in practice it looked very strange and unpleasing on some pages where such wines were in the great majority – so, in each range, at least one of such wines is given a short note as well as the rating (not according to any particular system that I’m aware of). The remainder of the lower-scoring wines are listed after the rubric “Also tasted:”, with just the name of the wine and the score.

Also, however, any NEW wine, tasted and rated for the first time in the guide, is also given a note, even if it scores 3.5 stars or less.

That’s it, I think. See? It’s quite simple, really. Isn’t it…?

You’ll also notice that there is no longer red ink used for wines scoring four stars or above. This change has no arcane significance. It helps Diners Club save money.

Incidentally, my understanding is that the online version of Platter will carry notes for ALL the wines.

Platter’s 2015: the winners

Here, along with the few special awards, are the wines rating five stars in the just-launched Platter’s South African Wines 2015 edition. The number is down from 80 last year to 50 (excluding brandies). I’ve commented on this, and made … Continue reading

Screwcaps, corks and foreplay

The case for using aluminium screwcaps to close wine bottles has long and convincingly been made. Few people, I imagine, would seriously argue that they are not efficient and convenient for the job at hand. The problem for the surgent … Continue reading

Savouring sauvignon

I don’t think it’s that I’ve grown to like sauvignon blanc much more over the past five or so years, rather that sauvignon blanc has grown to like me more. Cape sauvignon, that is, which I think has improved tremendously … Continue reading

Food und wein

I was hoping, against my better judgement for even more from this bottle – partly a sentimental hope, as it had travelled a long way to get to my fridge – from Germany to the USA and then to South … Continue reading