Getting (un)lucky on Saturday night

Well, if wine were entirely reliable, made entirely safely and sealed and delivered equally reliably, would we love it as much? Can a bit of tension in our lives be a bad thing?

Saturday evening started off well. Gloriously springlike weather it was, so I compensated for making an arguably wintry venison casserole by sipping, as I prepared it, some Secateurs Rosé 2014 – a perfectly delicious Adi Badenhorst triumph made from cinsaut, shiraz, grenache & carignan, just like a rosé should be. I’m sure it improved the casserole somehow, though the red wine I poured lavishly into the latter wasn’t one of Adi’s.

The next two moves were depressing, however. Continuing my uncertainty as to whether it was summer or winter, I decided on a lovely light, fresh syrah to accompany the vension (food and wine matching is not my strength; basically I want both food and wine to be nice, and that’s enough) – LAM Syrah 2012, from Lammershoek.

It was a touch too petillant, and a touch too funky for my mood. (I’d not had a problematic bottle of this wine before, though I’d be lying through my teeth if I said that I’d never had one of Craig Hawkins’ wines that showed signs of deciding to do a bit more fermentation in the bottle – nonetheless I’ve continued to buy, though I’m slowing down…)

saturdaySo I abandoned that bottle, and, sticking to the lighter side of syrah, decided on a great treat: my last bottle of Alain Graillot’s splendid Crozes-Hermitage 2005. No doubts here, the wine was disgusting – horribly corked. I felt quite viciously pleased that I’d just that day accepted an invitation to a presentation about developments in screwcaps (the fact that the accompanying lunch was at Jardine’s at Jordan had been, of course, immaterial in my rare acceptance of an invitation to any wine function).

The casserole was by now getting a bit chilly. And I was getting irritated.

I abandoned syrah in favour of cabernet franc (with cab sauv and bloody merlot!) in the form of Boekenhoutskloof’s The Journeyman 2005. Ah. Relief. Bliss, even. No cork taint. No fizziness, just a brilliantly good wine. I’ve suggested before that’s it’s probably one of the best Cape reds, and saw (tasted) no reason to change my opinion.

(Though I couldn’t help but remember the last time I opened a bottle of this wine, in a context where mostly pretty grand foreign wines were being drunk. An always  horribly acute taster immediately identified it as a South African wine. How? Because of a particular character which suggested to this person that the grapes had been grown in a vineyard with creosoted trellis poles. This subject, possibly connected with the notorious “burnt rubber” character of many Cape wines. is altogether too big and deep for me, especially right now. Though did you know that creosote is banned in Europe while it continues to be used in most vineyards and many other places here?)

Postscripts: I’ve been drinking The Journeyman again tonight, 24 hours later, and mostly I’m struck by how youthfully fruity and how beautifully structured it is – it  still seems to me a really excellent wine, and not for the first time, I’m very pleased that Im not a “technical taster”.

Further: I tonight opened another bottle of LAM Syrah 2012. VNervously, as I still have the better part of a case of it. A few bubbles, perhaps, but here the fruit was fuller, sweeter, fresher, not at all compromised, and the wine was as I remembered it. So, with luck, I’ll get quite a bit more pleasure out of what remains of the case. Cork and low sulphur additions permitting.

Syrah for Platter

I had the great pleasure the other day of tasting the 25 syrahs that had been nominated for five stars in the 2015 Platter Guide (see here for my pre-tasting remarks). Now, I have to keep pretty cagey about any … Continue reading

A new way to map the stars

For many tasters in the Platter Guide team, I suspect that the communal tasting of candidates for five stars – the guide’s ultimate accolade, as they say – is the highlight of the tasting season. For many consumers it produces … Continue reading

The two chenin revolutions

I’ve been writing a blog for the World of Fine website, about chenin blanc in South Africa, the Loire and California. I suddenly resolved a theory about the place of chenin in the revolution in Cape wines. Basically, it occurs … Continue reading