Craven wines, with a digression on bitterness

Jeanine and Mick Craven – a great pic stolen from

Mick and Jeanine Craven offer the main Stellenbosch outpost of radical natural(ish) winemaking in the Cape – its domicile being the Swartland – though there are others there, notably the Winery of Good Hope, who include such wines among their ranges. I add the “-ish” bit to “natural” (and the scrupulous Cravens would too)  as organically-farmed grapes should be seen as a vital component of the movement/set of practices that generally goes under the “natural” rubric. What Mick and Jeanine offer, then, in pretty small quantities, is early-picked freshness, spontaneous fermentation, some skin contact for white wines as well as red, minimal intervention (just a dash of sulphur at bottling, usually), and early maturation in old oak barrels. Honest stuff, no means cheap, but fairly priced.

It makes for attractive and very drinkable wines, as I was reminded when tasting their 2016 releases recently. The following notes reflect the order in which I tasted the wines.

Clairette Blanche 2016 (about R150), It’s a pretty neutral grape variety this, usefully drought-resistant, with (Mick points out) most of the flavour in the skins, so they use a mix of whole-bunch-fermented and skin-contact wines – about 60% of the latter, giving good aromas and flavour and a nice bit of tannic bite. It’s very light at 11% alcohol, but just about satisfactorily vinous. Fresh goes without saying….

Chenin Blanc “Karibib” 2016 (a little more than the Clairette). A new addition to the Craven portfolio, made from Polkadraai Hills fruit. A winning lightness to it, but with a degree more alcohol (at 12%) than the Clairette, which gives a balance/weight that I prefer. Bright and succulent, with a long-lingering finish. I love it.

Pinot Gris 2016 (pushing R200). Fermentation on the pale-red (“gris”) skins gives the wine its delightful orange-rosiness and no doubt contributes to its gorgeous aromas and pleasing flavours with a dry, slightly herbal note. And actually quite a shot of tannin. The 2016 is riper than I remember this wine being before, with an alochol of just over 13% – pretty heady stuff for the Cravens! I wonder if the skins also contribute the edge of bitterness that I found.

A digression
On which note, a digression…. I’ve always found my experience of bitterness unreliable, though I seem to get it more often than most people I taste with. One day I’ll find it in a wine, and not the next. I’m at present working through Jamie Goode’s excellent new book on the challenges of wine tasting, called I Taste Red, and recently arrived at some discussion of bitterness. Firstly of relevance, he says that “there are many chemical compounds that elicit bitter tastes, with quite different structures”; and he cites a researcher who “thinks that about one-third of people do not seem to get bitterness in wines at all”; there’s clearly a genetic factor working here. Which means that just because I found a bit of problematic bitterness in the Pinot Gris on the day doesn’t mean that you will. (I hope to do a review of Jamie’s book shortly.)

Cinsaut 2016 (pushing R200). Another new wine, this one from “a breath-taking vineyard up on the the Bottelary Hills”. Destemmed, which is unusual for the Cravens, but they say it helps retain acidity, which is useful for cinsaut. A little more challenging and characterful than many cinsauts, which can tend to be a bit facile, and quite the opposite of jammy. Beautifully dry, good balance; fresh and lively, but I’d ideally leave it in bottle for a year or three before drinking. A good addition to the Cape’s range.

Pinot Noir “Faure Vineyard” 2016 (pushing R200). As usual, from Jeanine’s family farm in Faure, Stellenbosch. A shy, light version, this, and not for keeping, I’d suggest. My least favourite of the bunch: I found it a little too austere, low on fruit and charm, with dry tannins.

Syrah “Faure Vineyard” 2016 (well past R200). Whole-bunch-fermented, off a rocky site. An excellent, successful example of an early-picked, light (just over 12% alcohol) syrah, that shows no greenness (not to me, anyway), is aromatic, fresh, charming and bright, but with good fruit and a supple, subtle succulent tannin structure. I’d love a look into the future to see how this will develop. I certainly wouldn’t gamble on it doing much beyond five years, but I confess that’s mostly a gut feeling.

Syrah “The Firs Vineyard” 2016 (price as for Faure version). From a Devon Valley site, made in the same way as the Faure version, but pretty different. My notes seem a bit contradictory, which is no doubt more my fault than the wine’s, though I do think it is less “together”, less complete than the other, and somehow tougher. It’s a touch lighter, but the aromas offer more fruit, though the palate has less intensity (but has a richer texture). Clearly I preferred the Faure one at this tasting, but there’s much interest here, and I could imagine liking this one too….

Sadie wins prestigious award

Eben Sadie last night, at ProWein in Germany, achieved the substantial honour of being the winner of the 2017 Winemakers’ Winemaker Award. The winner is chosen by winemakers who are Masters of Wine, plus previous winners. As the award has … Continue reading